
Aston Villa
vs.
Plymouth Argyle

Head to head record between Aston Villa and their opponents
Game #4007
1987-88
Graham Taylor | 🏴 | 1987-1990


Division Two
1st= (+1)
🟩 27 Feb 1988, Villa 5-2 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Stuart Gray (pen) | 20' | David Platt | 22' | Paul Birch | 26' | 76' | Garry Thompson | 74' |
Assist(s) | Tony Daley | 22' | 76' | Andy A Gray | 26' | Paul Birch | 74' |
Starting XI:
GK Nigel Spink | 🏴 |
RB Kevin Gage | 🏴 |
CB Allan Evans | 🏴 |
CB Martin Keown | 🏴 |
LB Bernie Gallacher | 🏴 |
M Paul Birch | 🏴 |
M Andy A Gray | 🏴 |
M David Platt | 🏴 |
M Stuart Gray | 🏴 |
W Tony Daley | 🏴 |
CF Garry Thompson | 🏴 |
Subs:
None
Game #3134
1971-72
Vic Crowe | 🏴 | 1970-1974


Division Three
🟩 14 Aug 1971, Villa 3-1 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Geoff Vowden | 10' | Pat McMahon | 20' | Willie Anderson | 75' (pen) |
Assist(s) | Pat McMahon | 10' | Geoff Vowden | 20' |
Starting XI:
GK Tommy Hughes | 🏴 |
RB Keith Bradley | 🏴 |
CB Fred Turnbull | 🏴 |
CB Brian Tiler | 🏴 |
LB Charlie Aitken | 🏴 |
M Harry Gregory | 🏴 |
M Pat McMahon | 🏴 |
M Willie Anderson | 🏴 |
W Ray Graydon | 🏴 |
F Geoff Vowden | 🏴 |
CF Andy Lochhead | 🏴 |
Subs:
M Chico Hamilton | 🏴 |
Game #2942
1967-68
Tommy Cummings | 🏴 | 1967-1968


Division Two
18th= (-6)
🟥 28 Aug 1967, Villa 0-1 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | None
Assist(s) | None
Starting XI:
GK Colin Withers | 🏴 |
RB Mick Wright | 🏴 |
CB John Sleeuwenhoek | 🏴 |
LB Charlie Aitken | 🏴 |
M Mike Tindall | 🏴 |
M Lew Chatterley | 🏴 |
M Willie Anderson | 🏴 |
M Dave Rudge | 🏴 |
W Johnny MacLeod | 🏴 |
F Peter Broadbent | 🏴 |
CF Barry Stobart | 🏴 |
Subs:
CF John Inglis | 🏴 |
Game #2612
1960-61
Joe Mercer | 🏴 | 1958-1964


League Cup
4th Round
🟨 19 Dec 1960, Villa 0-0 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | None
Assist(s) | None
GK Fred Potter | 🏴 |
FB Doug Winton | 🏴 |
FB John Neal | 🏴 |
CB Jimmy Dugdale | 🏴 |
M Vic Crowe | 🏴 |
M Alan Deakin | 🏴 |
W Jimmy MacEwan | 🏴 |
F Peter McParland | 🇬🇧 |
F Bobby Thomson | 🏴 |
F Gerry Hitchens | 🏴 |
F Ron Wylie | 🏴 |
Game #2554
1959-60
Joe Mercer | 🏴 | 1958-1964


Division Two
1st (-)
🟩 31 Oct 1959, Villa 2-0 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Jimmy MacEwan | 9' | Peter McParland | 17' |
Assist(s) | Ron Wylie | 9' | Pat Saward | 17' |
GK Nigel Sims | 🏴 |
FB John Neal | 🏴 |
FB Stan Lynn | 🏴 |
CB Jimmy Dugdale | 🏴 |
M Vic Crowe | 🏴 |
M Pat Saward | 🇮🇪 |
W Jimmy MacEwan | 🏴 |
F Peter McParland | 🇬🇧 |
F Gerry Hitchens | 🏴 |
F Ron Wylie | 🏴 |
F Bobby Thomson | 🏴 |
Game #1830
1936-37
Jimmy Hogan | 🏴 | 1936-1939


Division Two
7th=
🟩 13 Feb 1937, Villa 5-4 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Eric Houghton | 33' | 43' | 87' | Frank Broome | 47' | 70' |
Assist(s) | Freddie Haycock | 47' | 70' | 87' |
GK Harry Morton | 🏴 |
FB Bill Cobley |
FB George Cummings |
M Alex Massie |
M Tom Griffiths |
W John Maund |
W Eric Houghton |
F Bob Iverson |
F Freddie Haycock |
F Ronnie Starling |
CF Frank Broome |
Game #639
1905-06
George Ramsay | 🏴 | 1886-1926


FA Cup
2nd Round
🟨 3 Feb 1906, Villa 0-0 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | None
Assist(s) | None
GK Billy George |
FB Howard Spencer |
LB Jock Logan |
M George Harris |
M Joe Pearson |
M Jack Windmill |
W Albert Hall |
W George Garratt |
CF Billy Garraty |
CF Harry Hampton |
F Joe Bache |
Game #3979
1987-88
Graham Taylor | 🏴 | 1987-1990


Division Two
8th (+1)
🟩 3 Oct 1987, Villa 3-1 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Mark Walters | 2' | 39' | Mark Lillis | 9' |
Assist(s) | Alan McInally | 2' |
Starting XI:
GK Nigel Spink | 🏴 |
RB Kevin Gage | 🏴 |
CB Martin Keown | 🏴 |
CB Steve Sims | 🏴 |
LB Bernie Gallacher | 🏴 |
M Warren Aspinall | 🏴 |
M Paul Birch | 🏴 |
M Mark Lillis | 🏴 |
W Steve Hunt | 🏴 |
W Mark Walters | 🏴 |
CF Alan McInally | 🏴 |
Subs:
CB Allan Evans | 🏴 |
Game #3107
1970-71
Vic Crowe | 🏴 | 1970-1974


Division Three
2nd (-)
🟨 19 Dec 1970, Villa 1-1 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Andy Lochhead | 45' |
Assist(s) | Willie Anderson | 45' |
Starting XI:
GK John Dunn | 🏴 |
RB Keith Bradley | 🏴 |
CB Fred Turnbull | 🏴 |
CB Brian Tiler | 🏴 |
LB Charlie Aitken | 🏴 |
M Chico Hamilton | 🏴 |
M Willie Anderson | 🏴 |
M Pat McMahon | 🏴 |
F Brian Godfrey | 🏴 |
F Dave Gibson | 🏴 |
CF Andy Lochhead | 🏴 |
Subs:
None
Game #2940
1967-68
Tommy Cummings | 🏴 | 1967-1968


Division Two
🟥 23 Aug 1967, Villa 1-3 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Barry Stobart | 60' |
Assist(s) | Willie Anderson | 60' |
Starting XI:
GK Colin Withers | 🏴 |
RB Mick Wright | 🏴 |
CB John Sleeuwenhoek | 🏴 |
LB Charlie Aitken | 🏴 |
M Mike Tindall | 🏴 |
M Lew Chatterley | 🏴 |
M Willie Anderson | 🏴 |
W Johnny MacLeod | 🏴 |
F Peter Broadbent | 🏴 |
CF Barry Stobart | 🏴 |
CF John Inglis | 🏴 |
Subs:
M Dave Pountney | 🏴 |
Game #2610
1960-61
Joe Mercer | 🏴 | 1958-1964


League Cup
4th Round
🟨 13 Dec 1960, Villa 3-3 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Peter McParland | 48' | 56' | Jimmy MacEwan | 70' |
Assist(s) | None
GK Nigel Sims | 🏴 |
FB Doug Winton | 🏴 |
FB John Neal | 🏴 |
CB Jimmy Dugdale | 🏴 |
M Vic Crowe | 🏴 |
W Jimmy MacEwan | 🏴 |
F Peter McParland | 🇬🇧 |
F Bobby Thomson | 🏴 |
F Gerry Hitchens | 🏴 |
F Ron Wylie | 🏴 |
F Alan O'Neill | 🏴 |
Game #1877
1937-38
Jimmy Hogan | 🏴 | 1936-1939


Division Two
1st=
🟩 23 Feb 1938, Villa 3-0 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Frank Broome | 1-0 | John Maund | 2-0 | Freddie Haycock | 3-0 |
Assist(s) | John Maund | 1-0 | Frank Broome | 2-0 |
GK Bill Carey | 🏴 |
FB George Cummings |
RB Ernie Callaghan |
CB Jimmy Allen |
M Alex Massie |
W John Maund |
CF Frank Broome |
F Ronnie Starling |
F Bob Iverson |
F Freddie Haycock |
F Frank Shell |
Game #1810
1936-37
Jimmy Hogan | 🏴 | 1936-1939


Division Two
3rd=
🟨 10 Oct 1936, Villa 2-2 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Frank Broome | 9' | Dai Astley | 49' |
Assist(s) | George Hardy | 9' | Frank Broome | 49' |
GK Fred Biddlestone | 🏴 |
FB Bill Cobley | 🏴 |
CB Jimmy Allen | 🏴 |
M George Hardy | 🏴 |
M Alex Massie | 🏴 |
M Tom Griffiths | 🏴 |
M Tommy Gardner |
W Eric Houghton | 🏴 |
F Dai Astley | 🏴 |
F Ronnie Dix | 🏴 |
CF Frank Broome | 🏴 |
Game #3151
1971-72
Vic Crowe | 🏴 | 1970-1974


Division Three
4th= (-2)
🟥 16 Oct 1971, Villa 2-3 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Bruce Rioch | 59' | Geoff Vowden | 79' |
Assist(s) | Andy Lochhead | 59' | Chico Hamilton | 79' |
Starting XI:
GK Tommy Hughes | 🏴 |
LB Charlie Aitken | 🏴 |
CB George Curtis | 🏴 |
CB Brian Tiler | 🏴 |
D Keith Bradley | 🏴 |
M Chico Hamilton | 🏴 |
M Willie Anderson | 🏴 |
M Bruce Rioch | 🏴 |
W Ray Graydon | 🏴 |
F Geoff Vowden | 🏴 |
CF Andy Lochhead | 🏴 |
Subs:
None
Game #3079
1970-71
Vic Crowe | 🏴 | 1970-1974


Division Three
5th= (-)
🟨 22 Aug 1970, Villa 1-1 Plymouth, Villa Park
Scorer(s) | Pat McMahon | 27' |
Assist(s) | Lew Chatterley | 27' |
Starting XI:
GK John Dunn | 🏴 |
RB Mick Wright | 🏴 |
CB George Curtis | 🏴 |
LB Charlie Aitken | 🏴 |
M Lew Chatterley | 🏴 |
M Chico Hamilton | 🏴 |
M Pat McMahon | 🏴 |
M Bruce Rioch | 🏴 |
M Willie Anderson | 🏴 |
F Brian Godfrey | 🏴 |
CF Andy Lochhead | 🏴 |
Subs:
None
Game #2622
1960-61
Joe Mercer | 🏴 | 1958-1964


League Cup
4th Round
🟩 6 Feb 1961, Villa 5-3 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Harry Burrows | 45’ | Alan O’Neill | 59’ | Gerry Hitchens | 63’ | 70’ | 88’ |
Assist(s) | Jimmy MacEwan | 59’ | 63’ | Harry Burrows | 88’ |
GK Nigel Sims | 🏴 |
LB Doug Winton | 🏴 |
FB Stan Lynn | 🏴 |
RH Vic Crowe | 🏴 |
CH Jimmy Dugdale | 🏴 |
LH Alan Deakin | 🏴 |
W Jimmy MacEwan | 🏴 |
LW Harry Burrows | 🏴 |
IF Bobby Thomson | 🏴 |
F Alan O'Neill | 🏴 |
CF Gerry Hitchens | 🏴 |
Game #2585
1959-60
Joe Mercer | 🏴 | 1958-1964


Division Two
1st (-)
🟥 30 Apr 1960, Villa 0-3 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | None
Assist(s) | None
GK Nigel Sims | 🏴 |
FB John Neal | 🏴 |
FB Stan Lynn | 🏴 |
CB Jimmy Dugdale | 🏴 |
M Vic Crowe | 🏴 |
M Pat Saward | 🇮🇪 |
W Jimmy Adam | 🏴 |
F Peter McParland | 🇬🇧 |
F Bobby Thomson | 🏴 |
F Ron Wylie | 🏴 |
F Gerry Hitchens | 🏴 |
Game #1852
1937-38
Jimmy Hogan | 🏴 | 1936-1939


Division Two
2nd=
🟩 2 Oct 1937, Villa 3-0 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | Frank Broome | 44' | 50' | Eric Houghton | 3-0 |
Assist(s) | Freddie Haycock | 50' |
GK Fred Biddlestone | 🏴 |
LB George Cummings | 🏴 |
RB Ernie Callaghan | 🏴 |
CB Jimmy Allen | 🏴 |
M Alex Massie | 🏴 |
W Andy Kerr | 🏴 |
W Eric Houghton | 🏴 |
F Ronnie Starling | 🏴 |
F Freddie Haycock | 🏴 |
CF Frank Broome | 🏴 |
CF Bob Iverson | 🏴 |
Game #640
1905-06
George Ramsay | 🏴 | 1886-1926


FA Cup
2nd Round
🟩 7 Feb 1906, Villa 5-1 Plymouth, Home Park
Scorer(s) | George Garratt | 5' | Billy Garraty | 8' | 4-1 | Joe Bache | 11' | Harry Hampton | 52' |
Assist(s) | Albert Hall | 4-1 | 52' |
GK Billy George |
FB Howard Spencer |
LB Jock Logan |
FB Michael Noon |
M Joe Pearson |
M Jack Windmill |
W Albert Hall |
W George Garratt |
CF Billy Garraty |
CF Harry Hampton |
F Joe Bache |