| | Birmingham City | ๐จ 19 Sep 1903, Villa 2-2 Small Heath, Muntz Street |
| | Birmingham City | ๐จ 16 Jan 1904, Villa 1-1 Small Heath, Villa Park |
| | Blackburn Rovers | ๐ฅ 12 Dec 1903, Villa 2-3 Blackburn, Villa Park |
| | Blackburn Rovers | ๐ฉ 9 Apr 1904, Villa 3-0 Blackburn, Ewood |
| | Bury | ๐จ 5 Dec 1903, Villa 2-2 Bury, Gigg Lane |
| | Bury | ๐ฅ 2 Apr 1904, Villa 0-2 Bury, Villa Park |
| | Derby County | ๐ฉ 10 Oct 1903, Villa 3-0 Derby, Villa Park |
| | Derby County | ๐จ 28 Dec 1903, Villa 2-2 Derby, Baseball Ground |
| | Everton | ๐ฉ 26 Sep 1903, Villa 3-1 Everton, Villa Park |
| | Everton | ๐ฅ 23 Jan 1904, Villa 0-1 Everton, Goodison |
| | Liverpool | ๐ฉ 28 Nov 1903, Villa 2-1 Liverpool, Villa Park |
| | Liverpool | ๐จ 26 Mar 1904, Villa 1-1 Liverpool, Anfield |
| | Manchester City | ๐ฅ 17 Oct 1903, Villa 0-1 Manchester City, Hyde Road |
| | Manchester City | ๐ฅ 13 Feb 1904, Villa 0-1 Manchester City, Villa Park |
| | Middlesbrough | ๐ฅ 21 Nov 1903, Villa 1-2 Boro, Ayresome |
| | Middlesbrough | ๐ฉ 19 Mar 1904, Villa 2-1 Boro, Villa Park |
| | Newcastle United | ๐จ 2 Sep 1903, Villa 1-1 Newcastle, St James' |
| | Newcastle United | ๐ฉ 7 Nov 1903, Villa 3-1 Newcastle, Villa Park |
| | Nottingham Forest | ๐ฉ 19 Dec 1903, Villa 7-3 Forest, City Ground |
| | Nottingham Forest | ๐ฉ 16 Apr 1904, Villa 3-1 Forest, Villa Park |
| | Notts County | ๐ฉ 24 Oct 1903, Villa 4-0 Notts County, Villa Park |
| | Notts County | ๐จ 1 Apr 1904, Villa 0-0 Notts County, Trent Bridge |
| | Sheffield United | ๐ฉ 31 Oct 1903, Villa 2-1 Sheffield United, Bramall Lane |
| | Sheffield United | ๐ฉ 27 Feb 1904, Villa 6-1 Sheffield United, Villa Park |
| | Sheffield Wednesday | ๐ฉ 26 Dec 1903, Villa 2-1 Wednesday, Villa Park |
| | Sheffield Wednesday | ๐ฅ 23 Apr 1904, Villa 2-4 Wednesday, Owlerton |
| | Stoke | ๐ฅ 3 Oct 1903, Villa 0-2 Stoke, Victoria Road |
| | Stoke | ๐ฉ 30 Jan 1904, Villa 3-1 Stoke, Villa Park |
| | Sunderland | ๐ฅ 5 Sep 1903, Villa 1-6 Sunderland, Roker Park |
| | Sunderland | ๐ฉ 2 Jan 1904, Villa 2-0 Sunderland, Villa Park |
| | West Bromwich Albion | ๐ฉ 12 Sep 1903, Villa 3-1 Albion, Villa Park |
| | West Bromwich Albion | ๐ฉ 9 Jan 1904, Villa 3-1 Albion, Hawthorns |
| | Wolverhampton Wanderers | ๐ฉ 14 Nov 1903, Villa 2-0 Wolves, Villa Park |
| | Wolverhampton Wanderers | ๐ฅ 12 Mar 1904, Villa 2-3 Wolves, Molineux |